When Renton High School is torn down and replaced in the next four years, it won’t be a win for the environment. Yes, its replacement will have a “highly-efficient HVAC ” system and meet the “requirements of Washington Energy Code and Clean Building Act.” But constructing an all-new school instead of updating/expanding the existing one has a nearly insurmountable environmental cost. Millions of pounds of materials will be crushed and trucked to landfills, while millions of pounds of new materials will need to be mined, manufactured, and transported to replace them. It may take 80 years before an improved HVAC system overcomes this environmental impact, if it ever does.
In 2007 Carl Elefante, former president of the American Institute of Architects, summarized the new-vs-remodel dilema by pointing out that “the greenest building is the one that is already built.”
This link includes an excellent interview with Mr. Elefante, where he elaborates on this point. The argument that we should preserve buildings when possible extends far beyond Renton High School. We should be practicing it everywhere.
The Renton High replacement also involves tearing down 40 homes and businesses, which along with causing misery through unwanted takings and displacements, will also have to be replaced. And the new high school project will cut down hundreds of trees, more than the Renton code would typically allow for a site of this size. No amount of insulation in the new school will overcome the environmental cost of these impacts.
I voted along with the majority for the bond issue to build a new Renton High School, because I believed the district’s voter materials that said that the existing high school would be preserved and repurposed. The district’s voter information also made no mention of taking and destroying 40 homes and businesses.
Our Renton students deserve the very best high schools we can give them, but no one should be arguing that this particular plan for Renton High was the most environmentally friendly one.

One of 32 houses being torn down for the new school. There are also eight businesses being bulldozed.

This page from the “New Renton High” presentation on the School District’s website implies that the new high school will be a win for the environment. (It won’t be)










































Recent Comments